Σ Scriptorium Press · Editions worth owning · The Histories

Which translation of The Histories should you read?

Updated · each edition is described in its publisher’s own words, checked against the listing

10 in-print translations and 4 audiobooks, compared by who made them, when, and what each one is actually trying to do — Herodotus.

Start with Robin Waterfield (1998, Oxford World's Classics) for a first read; choose David Grene (1987, University of Chicago Press) to stay closest to the original. The longer answer. No single edition of The Histories is best for everyone, because the editions are optimised for different things: for a first read, the editions described as the most readable are Robin Waterfield, Aubrey de Selincourt, revised by John Marincola; to stay closest to the original, David Grene; on audio the choice is mostly which translation is being read and whether it is one narrator or a full cast.

Every claim below is the publisher’s or translator’s own description, shown next to it, so you can judge rather than take our word.

Buy Robin Waterfield on Amazon → Buy David Grene on Amazon →

Buy a print edition

Sorted as the research file records them. The note on each row is that edition’s own published description.

If you want the smoothest first read: Robin Waterfield (1998), Aubrey de Selincourt, revised by John Marincola (2003)
If you want to stay closest to the original: David Grene (1987)
If you are studying it, not just reading it: Robin Waterfield (1998), David Grene (1987), A. D. Godley (1920)
TranslatorYearPublisherWhat it is
Andrea L. Purvis2007Anchor Books (Pantheon/Random House)prose; maps/appendices/essays by Robert Strassler; most-recommended modern editionBuy on Amazon
Robin Waterfield1998Oxford World's Classicsprose; readable scholarly standard, extensive notesBuy on Amazon
Tom Holland2013Penguin Classicsprose; acclaimed contemporary literary translationBuy on Amazon
Aubrey de Sélincourt (rev. John Marincola)1954Penguin Classicsprose; classic mid-century translation, revised edition still in printBuy on Amazon
David Grene1987University of Chicago Pressprose; scholarly, close to the GreekBuy on Amazon
A. D. Godley1920Loeb Classical Library (Harvard University Press)Greek-English facing-page prose; scholarly standard reference editionBuy on Amazon
Walter Blanco1992W. W. Nortonprose; includes critical essays and background, popular for studentsBuy on Amazon
Andrea L. Purvis, edited by Robert B. Strassler2007Pantheon, The Landmark Herodotusheavily annotated with maps, marginal notes and appendices; the best edition for studyBuy on Amazon
Aubrey de Selincourt, revised by John Marincola2003Penguin Classicsthe long-standing accessible standard, revised notesBuy on Amazon
Pamela Mensch2014Hackettclose and engrossing, with James Romm's notesBuy on Amazon

Those are affiliate links. They cost you nothing extra and pay a small commission to the people who publish these editions, and to us.

Audiobooks to buy

The thing that most changes an audiobook of The Histories is which translation is being read — a scholarly text and a colloquial one are different listening experiences before the narrator says a word.

If you want the best-known recording: David Timson
NarratorTranslation readPublisherYearNotes
David TimsonAubrey de Selincourt (rev.)Naxos AudioBooks2016unabridged, ~27.5 hrs, AudioFile-praisedListen on Audible
Charlton GriffinA. D. GodleyAudio Connoisseur2007unabridged classic Loeb-era translationListen on Audible
Bernard MayesGeorge RawlinsonBlackstone Audio2007unabridged public-domain translationListen on Audible
Frank LavertyTom Holland (Penguin Classics)Penguin Audio2014modern acclaimed translation, unabridgedListen on Audible
If you listen to more than one of these a year, an Audible membership is usually cheaper than buying them singly. See the Audible membership plans · Premium Plus annual. Both renew automatically unless cancelled.

Affiliate links, including the Audible ones. They cost you nothing extra. Our own audiobook of The Histories stays free either way.

Older public-domain translations hosted elsewhere

Free public-domain translations elsewhere

Older translations, out of copyright, hosted free by Internet Archive, Perseus Digital Library, Project Gutenberg. Not our work and not affiliate links — they are here because they are genuinely useful.

TranslatorYearWhat it is
G. C. Macaulay (George Campbell Macaulay)1890Volume 1 (Books 1-4); companion Volume 2 at gutenberg.org/ebooks/2456; prose, widely usedProject Gutenberg →
A. D. Godley (Alfred Denis Godley)1920-1925Loeb prose translation, standard scholarly text, freely searchable/readable on PerseusPerseus Digital Library →
George Rawlinson1858-1860The most famous 19th-century annotated edition; multiple scanned copies of the 4 volumes on Archive.orgInternet Archive →
Henry Cary1876 (reprint of 1848 original)"A new and literal version from the text of Baehr"; literal prose renderingInternet Archive →
G. C. Macaulay1890Standalone excerpt of Macaulay's Book II (Egypt) issued as its own Gutenberg ebookProject Gutenberg →

Questions people ask

Which translation of The Histories is easiest to read first?

The editions described as the most readable are Robin Waterfield (1998), Aubrey de Selincourt, revised by John Marincola (2003). Their published descriptions emphasise pace and plain modern idiom rather than strict line-by-line fidelity, which is what makes them easier on a first pass.

Which translation of The Histories is closest to the original?

The editions noted for fidelity to the source are David Grene (1987) - described as literal, close to the received text, or annotated line by line.

Which translation of The Histories is the most recommended?

The most frequently recommended are Andrea L. Purvis (2007), Robin Waterfield (1998), A. D. Godley (1920). "Most recommended" is not the same as "best for you": a scholarly standard and an easy first read are different books, and the table on this page shows which is which.

What is the best audiobook of The Histories?

There are 4 commercial recordings. They differ mainly in which translation is being read and whether it is a single narrator or a full cast: David Timson reads Aubrey de Selincourt (rev.); Charlton Griffin reads A. D. Godley; Bernard Mayes reads George Rawlinson. A complete free audiobook of our own translation is also on this site.

Is there a free version of The Histories?

Yes. Scriptorium Press publishes a complete new plain-English translation of The Histories free to read, with a complete free audiobook, no account and no paywall - 9 works in this volume.

Compiled from 5 free, 10 in-print and 4 audio editions recorded in our editions research file. Prices are deliberately not listed here because they change. · All volumes → · The free library →